Top 10 Best Cheeseburgers in Ohio
Ohio's best cheeseburgers — Columbus, Cincinnati, Toledo and beyond.
Ohio's cheeseburger scene includes inventive smash-burger spots, specialty burger restaurants, regional tavern favorites, and newer concepts that have quickly built loyal followings. This Discovery Matt ranking highlights standout burgers across Columbus, Findlay, Delaware, Toledo, Strongsville, Cincinnati, Newton Falls, and Richfield.
- 1
Stacked Burger Co
ColumbusStacked Burger Co earns the top spot for its dedicated burger identity and creative menu of specialty builds. It feels like a restaurant designed specifically to compete in this category rather than simply offering burgers among many other dishes.
Known for: Specialty burgers, Columbus favorite
- 2
Jack-B's
FindlayJack-B's ranks highly as one of Ohio's strongest cheeseburger names outside the state's largest cities. Its position reflects local enthusiasm and standout burger reputation.
Known for: Findlay burger destination
- 3
Smash Shack Burgers
DelawareSmash Shack Burgers gives Delaware a strong statewide representative and brings a focused smash-burger identity to the list. It ranks high for clarity of concept and strong appeal.
Known for: Smash burgers, Delaware favorite
- 4
Smash Buddies
ColumbusSmash Buddies brings a stripped-down, craveable smash-burger concept to Columbus. Its high placement reflects how well it fits current burger demand and the broader city food scene.
Known for: Smash burgers, Columbus buzz
- 5
Burger Hub
ToledoBurger Hub earns its top-five placement by giving Toledo a strong dedicated burger representative. It stands out as one of Northwest Ohio's better cheeseburger destinations.
Known for: Toledo cheeseburger favorite
- 6
CleaveLand Grill
StrongsvilleCleaveLand Grill adds a more neighborhood-oriented burger destination to the statewide list. Its local recognition helps it stand out in Northeast Ohio.
Known for: Strongsville burger spot
- 7
Heyday
CincinnatiHeyday gives Cincinnati a more stylish, contemporary burger entry. It belongs on the list for combining strong category appeal with a restaurant identity that feels current.
Known for: Cincinnati modern burger experience
- 8
Big D's Newton Grill
Newton FallsBig D's Newton Grill stands out with a broad specialty cheeseburger menu and playful burger creativity. It brings real personality to the ranking and earns a spot for being memorable.
Known for: Specialty burgers, Newton Falls favorite
- 9
Milkman
CincinnatiMilkman pairs burgers with a retro diner-bar feel and broader comfort-food appeal. It ranks here as a notable Cincinnati burger destination with a clear identity.
Known for: Burgers, shakes, OTR atmosphere
- 10
Whitey's Booze N' Burgers
RichfieldWhitey's rounds out the list as a longstanding local favorite with burgers at the heart of its identity. Its tavern energy and regional following make it a strong closer.
Known for: Richfield tavern burgers, local institution
How this ranking was built
Discovery Matt rankings are curated using a mix of public ratings, review volume, local reputation, menu identity, and overall standout appeal within each category.
Get new Discovery Matt food rankings sent to your inbox.
New rankings drop weekly. Be the first to see new state-by-state lists, hidden gems, and the full rankings behind the videos.
Think we missed one?
Submit a restaurant or food spot you think should be considered for a future Discovery Matt ranking.
Suggest a SpotOwn a restaurant or food brand?
Explore a potential ranking feature or brand collaboration with Discovery Matt.
Work With Discovery Matt