Florida Key Lime Pies

Top 10 Best Key Lime Pies in Florida

A curated ranking of the top key lime pies in Florida, based on reputation, consistency, and standout local appeal.

Few desserts are more closely connected to Florida than Key lime pie. The state’s best versions balance a bright, citrus-forward filling with condensed-milk sweetness, a buttery crust, and toppings that range from fresh whipped cream to towering toasted meringue. Across Florida, pie lovers can find century-old recipes in Key West, chocolate-dipped frozen slices in Tavernier, shortbread-crusted tarts in West Palm Beach, and beloved waterfront desserts from Islamorada to Cocoa Beach. This Discovery Matt Food Map ranking highlights Florida Key lime pies that stand out for flavor balance, texture, crust quality, consistency, originality, historical significance, and local reputation.

1
Kermit’s Key Lime Shop
Key West
Kermit’s Key Lime Shop takes the top spot as one of Florida’s most recognizable Key lime pie destinations. Its traditional pie delivers the creamy texture, tart citrus flavor, and graham-cracker crust expected from a classic Key West version. The frozen chocolate-dipped pie bar has become nearly as famous as the original slice, giving visitors two distinct ways to experience the signature dessert.
Known for: Classic Key lime pie, chocolate-dipped pie bars, creamy citrus filling, Key West tradition
2
Blue Heaven
Key West
Blue Heaven serves one of the most visually memorable Key lime pies in Florida. Each slice is crowned with a towering layer of lightly toasted meringue that creates a dramatic contrast with the tart, creamy filling and graham-cracker crust. The colorful Bahama Village setting makes the experience as memorable as the dessert itself.
Known for: Towering toasted meringue, tart filling, graham-cracker crust, Bahama Village atmosphere
3
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory
Tavernier
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory is one of the Florida Keys’ most dedicated dessert destinations. Its traditional Key lime pie combines a smooth filling with a crisp crust, while the frozen chocolate-covered pie on a stick provides a richer alternative. The tropical garden and pie-focused menu make it a natural stop along the Overseas Highway.
Known for: Traditional Key lime pie, chocolate-covered pie bars, tropical garden, Tavernier destination
4
Joe’s Stone Crab
Miami Beach
Joe’s Stone Crab may be most famous for seafood, but its Key lime pie has developed an equally devoted following. The filling is smooth, tangy, and restrained enough to avoid becoming overly sweet, while the graham-cracker crust adds richness and texture. Generations of diners have made the pie an essential finish to a classic meal at Joe’s.
Known for: Classic Key lime pie, balanced tartness, graham-cracker crust, historic Miami Beach dining
5
Key West Key Lime Pie Company
Key West
Key West Key Lime Pie Company specializes in an icebox-style pie based on a longstanding family recipe. Each pie is made with Key lime juice, a handmade graham-cracker crust, and a chilled filling that develops a firm but creamy texture. Visitors can order slices, whole pies, frozen bars, or even participate in a pie-making experience.
Known for: Icebox-style pie, handmade crust, frozen pie bars, pie-making experiences
6
Old Key Lime House
Lantana
Old Key Lime House pairs its signature dessert with one of South Florida’s most distinctive waterfront settings. The pie features a creamy citrus filling, fresh whipped cream, and a substantial cinnamon-accented graham-cracker crust. Its historic building, colorful exterior, and Intracoastal views make it one of the state’s most atmospheric places to enjoy a slice.
Known for: Cinnamon graham-cracker crust, whipped cream, waterfront dining, historic Florida atmosphere
7
Ganache Bakery Cafe
West Palm Beach
Ganache Bakery Cafe offers a distinctive interpretation built around an individual shortbread crust. The buttery shell provides a crisp foundation for the bright Key lime filling, creating a dessert that feels more like a refined tart than a conventional restaurant slice. Its balance of tart citrus and rich pastry makes Ganache one of Florida’s strongest Key lime destinations outside the Keys.
Known for: Shortbread crust, individual Key lime tarts, bright citrus filling, boutique bakery setting
8
Fookem’s Fabulous
Coconut Grove
Fookem’s Fabulous brings a creative, modern personality to Miami’s Key lime pie scene. Its signature pies emphasize a rich, tart filling supported by carefully developed crusts and toppings, while specialty versions incorporate flavors such as espresso and coconut. The Coconut Grove storefront has helped transform the business from a local specialty producer into a destination dessert shop.
Known for: Handcrafted Key lime pies, specialty flavors, creative crusts, Coconut Grove shop
9
The Florida Key Lime Pie Company
Cocoa Beach
The Florida Key Lime Pie Company gives the Space Coast a shop devoted to Florida desserts and regional products. Its traditional pie uses a longstanding Florida family recipe and delivers the sweet-tart balance visitors expect from a classic version. Frozen slices, chocolate-covered treats, tropical desserts, and the colorful all-Florida shop add to the experience.
Known for: Traditional Florida recipe, frozen Key lime treats, tropical desserts, Cocoa Beach location
10
Key Lime Pie Lady at Trading Post
Islamorada
Key Lime Pie Lady rounds out the ranking with a traditional, handmade pie produced in the Florida Keys. The pies are sold at several local retailers, including the Trading Post in Islamorada, making them an easy addition to an Overseas Highway road trip. The straightforward preparation and locally crafted identity capture the appeal of a homemade Keys dessert.
Known for: Handmade Key lime pie, traditional preparation, locally crafted desserts, Islamorada availability

How this ranking was built

Discovery Matt Food Map rankings are curated using a mix of filling flavor, citrus intensity, sweetness, texture, crust quality, topping balance, consistency, originality, historical significance, local reputation, and overall destination appeal. For this Florida ranking, extra weight was given to businesses where Key lime pie is a signature product rather than an incidental dessert. Kermit’s earned the No. 1 position because it offers both an excellent traditional pie and one of Florida’s most recognizable Key lime creations in its frozen chocolate-dipped bar. Blue Heaven ranked closely behind for its dramatic meringue-topped presentation and memorable Key West atmosphere, while Blond Giraffe provides one of the Keys’ most complete pie-focused experiences. The Florida Keys received several positions because the region remains the cultural center of Key lime pie. Miami Beach, Coconut Grove, Lantana, West Palm Beach, and Cocoa Beach were included to recognize noteworthy versions across South Florida, Palm Beach County, Miami-Dade County, and the Space Coast. Major national restaurant and bakery chains were excluded. Locally founded businesses with a small number of locations remained eligible when their identity and reputation continued to be closely connected to Florida.

Newsletter